10th DEC 2010, 4.30pm
Preamble:
Approximately 12
hours ago (around 4.00 AM) I changed my earlier decision/s of not writing any
more – whatever in Kannada or English – (not to write my autobiography was the
other decision taken many years ago) and suppose what “caused “ this change of
decision is the visit on the 13th of this month, of Keremane Shivananda Hegde (wellknown
Yakshagana artist, Director, Idgunji Yakshagana Academy), who spent about 45–50
minutes talking (listening really) to me and urged me to write my
autobiography. I reiterated my decision not to write. He took several
photographs of me by his digital camera – on the Verandah talking to him,
standing on the steps, and a few in the garden (this was my suggestion) Additionally,
my being engrossed with the reading of M. S. Gore autobiography –“Memories That
Linger” along with some writing on DSSW – based on his account of it, may also
have been responsible for this decision to write. I made the decision, lying in
bed awake around 4 AM (4-15 AM) and thought of the title around 4-40AM. So here I am beginning my last piece of
writing.
It should be made very clear that I am not
writing my autobiography. I stick to the original decision. If I were to
write that (autobiography) it would have been in Kannada. What I am writing is
my memories of mainly my academic – professional life – selecting some
experiences and events – then writing on those – not following any
strict chronological order.
Background :
My childhood briefly and early education –
primary and secondary. I was born on 09-06-1930 at village Banavasi, Taluk – Sirsi
(now called Tehsil) of North Kanara (N. K.) district of the then Bombay province
of British India . My
district is a costal dist. South of Goa and north of the then South
Kanara district of Madras province. The capital of Bombay province was Bombay
– hence the name, carried out as an administrative territory of colonial India by
Elphinstone – the first Governor.
The Bombay province was a multilingual
province - Gujarat in the North -
beginning from Godhra (in news in recent years after the Godhra Massacre)
including – Ahmedabad, Surat, Baroch as major towns – cities the Marathi speaking
districts in the middle - biggest of the three linguistic groups, including
Nashik, Bombay, Pune, Thane Sangli, Satara cities – towards then the South –
four districts of Karnataka – Kannada speaking Belgaum, Bijapur, Dharwad and my
district, as the last district in the South. Very backward district. 75 –
80p.c. forest – poor roads) no railway line, heavy rainfall, malaria and othert
causes leading to de-population, due to malaria mainly and other diseases.
Educationally backwards in many ways – including inadequate primary schools in
many villages – only one Municipal City school – Sri Marikamba High School at
Sirsi (my taluk) covering approximately half of the district above the Western
Ghats - the other half - Coastal taluks. Heavy rainfall – mainly
agricultural – paddy, sugarcane, coconut plantations on the coastal areas and
Arecanut (supari), black pepper, cardamom and banana plantations in the above
ghat areas – my village part of this in the middle part of adjoining thick
forests – vast area of paddy fields.
The village around six centuries ago was the
new capital of a new dynasty established by King Mayura Varma, with a temple of Madhukeshwara
and a small river - Varada flowing on three sides – surrounding it in a “U” shape,
a tributary of Tunga (Bhadra), ultimately joining the major river Krishna . The village is on an elevation, so not affected
by floods – common during the rainy season, though the paddy fields get
submerged – causing much suffering to the agriculture – dependent population.
The village Banavasi has (for a long time) a Primary Govt. Boys School upto 7th standard
leading to (then prevalent system) a public examination – Primary School Leaving
Certificate Exam, PSLC – “Moolki” in Kannada (original in Urdu – meaning
regional). There were two more schools one for girl’s upto 4th standard
and one for Muslims – Urdu – a single teacher school, Girls school had two lady
teachers. An Agricultural Co-Op Credit Society – which had a small library
including books in Kannada, a Kannada daily from Hubli – Samyukta Karnataka
(United Karnataka) which arrived from sirsi at night and to read the next day.
Also twice weekly “Kesari” in Marathi – founded by Lokamanya Balgangadhar
Tilak, and small district news weekly – called Kanada Vrartta (Kannada).
My own interest in reading began at the age
of 7 or 8, reading Kannada detective novels – brought home by the visiting
uncle “ Shyanubhog” (village revenue official) during his visits and stay of a
week, 2 or 3 times a year. Picked up reading news papers – both Kannada and
Marathi, when my father could not read them due to poor eye sight after his
retirement – i. e. when I was studying at Sirsi High School, was familiar with
Devanagari script because I had to study Sanskrit as a subject from 4th
standard to 7th standard - end of high school with the terminating –
Matriculation Examination of Bombay University. The village also had a Police
Station with three constables and bus trip once at 7:00 am to Sirsi and return
at night by 8:00 pm - private bus service.
The population of the village was approximately
1000 to 1500. at present it is 7000. No medical facilities – no dispensary –
Public/private – not a single MBBS doctor until the 1950’s. When a Primary
Health Centre was started - with one MBBS doctor. Around the same time a High
School – Jayanti High School started.
End 5:30 PM
My Education
Primary school education at Banavasi upto 6th
standard, left towards the end (3 months before) as part of my father’s plan to
admit me at Sirsi - Marikamba High School, to study at Siddapur – Taluk HQ( a small
town? Big village?) to study and complete 6th standard and 7th
standard, along with one hour a day (one period) to study English at the Anglo
– Vernacular (A.V) School - single
teacher- teaching English . I passed the 6th standard with Hindi as
a subject (special tuition to pass this subject as I had not to study Hindi at
Banavasi) and 3rd standard. English at the A. V. school – with these
certificates I was eligible to be admitted to the 4th standard of
Sirsi High School, which I joined in June 1942 continued upto 1946.
Later I
had to go Hubli to study (formally) briefly at the City High School and passed
my Matriculation Exam of Bombay University in 2nd class – probably
53 p.c. at Sirsi – no hostel facilities – so stayed in a room, bathing, toilet
+ meals at a restaurant, popular called – Hotel, near the Bus stand – cheap and
“filthy”. Later for three years a cash
based hostel was started in a rented house – part of a “Chawl”- row of houses
in one long structure – with common toilet, bathing (for the house) and one
well – for water supply.
The main thing to remember is I developed
serious interest in Kannada literature, due to the influence of the Kannada teacher “GK Master” popularly called
G. K. Hegde, formed a literary club – “Kiriyara Koota” (“youngsters club”)
became the Executive president and Editor, of the handwritten Quarterly
magazine - “Hoovina Sara” (Garland of
Flowers). Started a small
library – bought books – (without pocket money – long story how this was done)
– others also contributed. Presided over dialogues (discussions on literary issues
- e.g. Progressive literature Vs Traditional Literature etc. The president was
Ramakrishna Hegde (R. K. Hegde) who later became Chief Minister of Karnataka from
1983 Jan to Aug 1988, Dy, Chairman Planning Commission, under V. P. Sing as
Prime Minister and Commerce Minister under Atal Bihari Vaajapeyi N.D.A Government
One of the founder members was T. Sheegehalli, N. T. Hegde Sheegehalli (V; T;
Sheegehalli V., Tie whose major novel “Talegali” “End of a Generation” 440 pp I
published posthumously April end this year (2010). His novel - the first he
wrote and was the last, became a best seller list – No. 1 and No. 2 reviewed favorably
by three Famous Kannada Literary Critics.
I am
sad, very sad he is not alive to enjoy the popularity and fame the novel
generated! To note – I read most of then Kannada Books published – all varieties
– poetry, drama, novel, biography, essays etc. Kannada (Navodaya) Rerhaissance
literature, developed fluently to speak and write in Kannada. I am proud to
say, I have to this day retained the proficiency? Command? Of spoken and
written Kannada. I could not have done all that I did for the posthumous
publication of “Talegali” novel – including a Glossary, an Appendix – Havyakas
– Their language and literature, but for this foundation, while at SIRSI.
There
was a price to pay – not inevitable – but it happened. I failed in the High
School - ending Public Examination (again a long story) - in 1946 – but briefly,
decided to discontinue (any reapperancy) my further education. I changed my
mind – thanks to the timely guidance and advice + help of my senior friend and
well wisher from the village – late C. C. Mulgund. I went to Hubli, took tuition
in mathematics (because the Sirsi High School teacher had to leave and he had joined
the City High School at Hubli. He, Mr. Talegaonkar,
alone could have helped me to pass the Matriculation Exam of Bombay University
in 1947 and I did that – with just three months tuition in Maths and English –
rest self study (6.30PM)
I shall now write briefly about my college
education at Dharwad which was then a well known educational centre – the
famous Karnatak College
– later became the nucleus of Karnataka
University in 1951 – the
year I was to appear for my final B.A. Honors. Exam, until then it was
part of Bombay University
– one of the oldest three or four universities of India since Pre Independence
time.
I
joined Karnatak College in June 1947, opting for Arts.
B.A. and then choosing Economics Honors – as my course. You could do either
pass or Honors. I chose the latter. Apart from compulsory English Paper –
although (four years) the Honors course (2 years) one had to choose 6 papers as
the main subject course and one subsidiary course – choice of one of then
available – history or Political Science. I chose the Political Science
subject. For Hons in Economics – there were six compulsory papers- including 4
theory courses + Economic History (Germany ,
UK , USA , Japan
and India )
+ Indian Economic Problems. Among the recommended books – well known authors-
Crowther – Story of Money, Gilchrist – on monetary and other theories J. M. Keyns
had burst on the economic scene – with his classic – General Theory of Employment.
He is a big name, even to - day as one of the
major contributors to the development of Economic Science /discipline. Economics
had begun to be written about with mathematic formulas/models. I should mention
as part of the theory courses – we had to study – Growth of Economic Thought.
Prof. S Dhekne and R. G. Sahsrabudhe – both of the Bombay Educational
Service – (Marathi speaking) Sahsrabudhe taught the main Econ. Papers,
perhaps one of them taught Political Science. The book for this – Harold Laski
– Grammer of Politics. Director of London
School of Economics – big
name also influenced a generation of students/politicians (especially Labour
Party). Jawahar Lal Nehru was one of the person influenced by Harold Laski.
For Indian Economic Problems only books
available – also recommended were Jathar and Berry , and Wadia and Merchant – co authors.
While I read both of these books. I relied mainly on Wadia and Merchant, read –
D. S. Sawakar – Economic History, S. G. Panandikar – Central Bank in India (meaning RBI). Note that I always read –
purchased most of the recommended books
– did read guides – very few, not more than two one was on Indian Economic
Problems- one of the better type – I think one of the author was Dewett. As
part of compulsory English, we had to study Shakespeare’s dramas – “As you like
it” – then for second year - known as Intermediate
Exam. Public Exam of Bombay
University . Some other
books – I don’t remember.
For the first two years – Kannada and
Sanskrit (actually a choice I exercised at High School) were the compulsory
papers. This meant I had studied, Kannada and Sanskrit as one of the subjects
since my 4th standard High School + two years in college – total six
years of my education. So, also English for six years – compulsory.
I may repeat, if I wrote earlier, that I
studied at a Govt. primary school. All taught in Kannada medium –at the Municipal
High School – also Kannada medium, except for Maths, Science and of course –
English – also Sanskrit – because the Sanskrit teacher Aras did not know
Kannada – being a Goan origin, he spoke only Konkani – his mother tongue Back
to College – well known teachers taught various subjects- Principal, Correa Afonso (formally of Stxaviers College Bombay)
Armando Mehezes, V. M. Inamdar, W. W. Bhaskar – taught English. Prof. S S. Malwad
(he later became principal of the college) and
R. K. Malgi taught Kannada. Prof. R. V. Jagirdar and Mr. Kulkarni taught
Sanskrit. I had to study Kalidasa’s classic (Meghadoota) and Mudra Rakshasa – a
drama. Prof. Jagirdar had a degree from London University .
(*All teachers were recruited to Bombay Educational Service.) He was also a
well known Kannada dramatist – writing under the pen name “Shree Ranga”, a big
name in Renaissance period Kannada literature.
I have always, for a longtime at least, felt uncomfortable
when talking and writing in English. You
may call it – inferiority Complex because I had not been to English Medium big
name schools. Though Karnatak
College – Dharwad was on
of the five colleges run directly by Bombay Govt and was very well known. Playright, theatre personality, actor,
director- Girish Karnad also studied at Sirsi and the same college where I
studied. He however had no problem in speaking, writing in English. He
originally wrote in Kannada, his dramas. Later translated in English and then
it was translated in other Indian languages. His mother tongue is Konkani. He
can speak well in Marathi. He addressed Marathi literary conference in Marathi.
I am not that talented. I can now, write and speak in English reasonably well.
Can speak and write in Kannada. And can read and speak Hindi, read Marathi to a
great extent - follow 70-80 pc of what I read; I can understand Konakni,
Gujarathi and Punjabi to a limited extent. I can’t read Urdu but can follow, when
spoken if it is not highly Persianised or Arabicised. 7-45 pm
MY EXPERIENCE OF WRITING
12-12-10, 11-30 am
What I
am about to write may be considered a “digression” but is related to what I
have written before this – i. e my academic background (more written later) and
knowledge of language – limited though it might have been. As a teenager (15-17
years) at Sirsi – Hubli, I wrote a few articles in Kannada including a
political pamphlet – “Quit Goa” (Goveyinda chale javo) with the help and
encouragement of Mr. Kulkund Shiva Rao (later known as “Niranjana”, novelist –
short story writer etc) who was then a cardholding member of the Communist
Party of India. (1946-1950) which was one big party. Later split in to two CPI
and CPI (M). P. C. Joshi was the General Secretary until 1948 – afterwards B.
T. Ranadive – displacing him on ideological grounds.
More militant and political line. The Party
was banned, many leaders went underground and some were arrested and put in jails.
Shiva Rao also went underground - with a secret new name - using my address for
secret party correspondence. The CID police got to know this and my name
entered the CID list – as a dangerous communist. The pamphlet quit gor got me
lot of publicity among Sirsi friends and literary circles. I became an
“author”. This association with Shiva Rao and CPI influenced me to the extent
that I became an active “Political” worker – not a member, described as a
“fellow traveler”.
I had come under the influence of my Hindi
teacher – “Dhareswar Master” who was a Khaddar – wearing Nationalist –
participant in freedom movement. I also started wearing “Khaddhar” – white
Gandhi cap and participated in a small way in the “Quit India” movement in 1942
at Sirsi being “crowned” as a leader who organised a protest procession when
one of our teachers – ‘ Vaman Hodke’ was arrested.
I had not organised the procession, - only
participated. But the English teacher at the high school – S. V. Kamat – Anglophile,
in the class announced that, “Pathak, you have been the leader, I understand” –
I kept quiet.
Getting back to my writing experience, I
attempted a long article in English while in second year of college – on the
“Unification of Karnatak” sent it to “Bharat Jyoti” Sunday edition of the wellknown
daily “Free Press Journal” ed. S. Sadanand, published from Bombay. I was
surprised to find that it was published while reading the weekly at the local
library. Next surprise – received an honorarium of Rs.20/- - big amount those
days- equivalent of 50 pc of my monthly expenditure and I was happy, elated.
After joining D.S.S.W. in July 1955 I was
asked by the Principal M. S. Gore to write a brief article on “Medical Social
Work” for the monthly “Social Welfare”. The editor, Frieda Bedi had asked the
principal who in turn asked me to write. My first “Professional” writing – I suppose
in 1956. I had used two or three brief case illustrations in my article. The
editor, mother of Kabir Bedi – Actor, edited out most part of it and retained
the case illustrations – which were printed prominently. Subsequently –
following a decision of staff meeting – that there should be regular seminars
based on a paper written by a staff member. The “Privilege” of writing the
first such paper (no one wrote subsequently) was either suggested by M.S.G. and
or volunteered/accepted by me. The topic was “Applicability of Social case work
Method in India ”.
Those were the days (period) when DSSW staff and other professionals outside
like P.D.Kulkarni, were very critical of case work and had argued that it was
not suitable for our country, which faced “Mass problems – Poverty; illiteracy
and illhealth. Casework as an individual – oriented approach was unsuitable and
“expensive”, even “wasteful”.
I took
the challenge – worked hard – read a great deal and produced a first draft of
closely type (single space) 30 pages – K. L. Raizada did the typing. I gave it
to MSG for comments. Based on those I was to revise the paper. His one comment
– I did not accept- did not agree. I had followed the universally accepted
academic practice of referring to an author – Celebrity be may be – by the last
name e.g. Gandhi, without prefix or suffix. MSG’s suggestion was that I should
refer to him as either Mahatma Gandhi or Gandhiji. I have been influenced by
Gandhi as a teenager, to this day I hold him in high respect. But I felt I had
not made any mistake – showed any disrespect. There was another comment – also
not acceptable to me.
I had
quoted “Albert Schweitzer’ internationally known medical doctor – working in
the field of leprosy relief. He (Albert Schweitzer) had three doctorates – one
from Indian Philosophy! I had quoted him from - an article published in ‘”Atlantic
Monthly”. USA which I had
purchased while in USA
in 1958 and read the article. MSG’s suggestions / comment was that he is not
accepted as an authority on Indian philosophy.
Quote – someone like S. Radhe Krishnan. I had read book/s of S. R. as
well as another famous author – Prof. M. Hriyanna of Mysore University.
Irony is that later, when MSG wrote a major paper
on attitudes to wealth – published in – “Economic and Cultural Change”. Ed. by
Bert Hoselitz of Chicago
University , he Quoted
from Albert Schweitzer in the same context - Indian Philosophical tradition! A.
S. I was told not an authority, but he became so, when MSG felt the need to quote
him! A negative feeling developed in my mind about MSG – due to this episode,
which perhaps, influenced my academic relationship with him. Outcome of this
was is my first major professional paper – on social case work, remains unpublished
to this day. I still have the MS with MSG’s handwritten comments in ink and Prof.
Herbert H. Apteker’s comments in pencil. I made no attempt to revise,
prepare another one/ two drafts as I would have done.
Dr.
Aptekar - as sought by me, gave his opinion that the M. S. was worthy of
publication – without any major revision. (Some revision would have been
there). I had thought of sending this M. S. for publication to the Indian
Journal of Social Work – TISS (Director is Ex – officer, Editor of the Journal).
Unfortunately for me MSG became Director TISS in June 1962 – succeeding Prof.
A. R. Wadia. I made no attempt to send it to IJSWK; Thereafter, I took a
decision - so long as MSG was Editor – I would not send anything for
publication on my own initiative. But, would do so if invited. I stuck
to that decision – even after he retired and other’s succeeded him. My articles
published in J. S. W. All of them are invitational
articles. Two articles – one on supervision and the other – review article on
G. R. Bannargies (GRB) book Papers on Social Work were published when MSG was
the editor of IJSW. When the essay review was send to him he wrote a brief acknowldgement
letter in which he said – “a thoughtful review”.
When TISS under A. R. Wadia, planned a book
on the occasion of its silver jubilee, History and Philosophy of Social Work in
India, I was chosen – a great honour at that time youngest, I was 30-31 years
of age, and had been a teacher at D.S.S.W. for about five or six years. I could
guess Dr. GRB had recommended my name – she was the founder – promoter of
Medical – Social Work in India .
She could have been the best/appropriate person to write it. She wrote on
social casework. This article on medical Social Work is the first major
published article on Social Work by me.
It
brought a good deal of reputation as a young academic and I began to be noticed
– invited for articles. Dr. Bannarjee has always been appreciative of me both
as a student and later as a professional colleges Even obliged me by agreeing
to write an article to “Social Work Forum” when I took over as the Editor in
1969 – and remained in that position for about 2 years. She wrote - that she
would not have accepted the invitation because she had decided not to write for
S.W.F for some reason, but would do so as I had invited her. A reciprocal
gesture because I have declined an invitation because of MSG., later agreed to
write for the seminar on supervision – other request another major paper, liked
by GRB, published in IJSW later, as part of the seminar papers!
Again, another digression – and I write about
Social Work Forum (SWF). I was invited by K. D. Gangrak the newly elected
president of ATSW to become the Editor and had agreed on my terms – full
control as Editor and Chairman, Editorial Advisory Board. SWF was behind
schedule, two issues had not come out and financially in debt. The Press Kumar
Printers was not paid for – due old bills and there was a “legal” notice from
Mr. M. K. Bhargava Rs. 1000/- were due, big money in 1969-70. I knew MKB
socially – was a friend – told him that I would personally advance Rs. 1000/-
from my fund – to be reimbursed later.
That
was what happened. I brought out SWF on schedule – making up the back log, ensured
that the journal kept to the schedule, improved the quality – by way of
articles, increased the number of subscribers, got (Mrs. V. Bala helped) new
Advts. Introduced a new feature – “Social Welfare News” which I prepared with
much hard work - going through several
English newspapers – covering different regions – Hindu for example – the
South, ‘Statesman’ for the East/North (Delhi Edu.), Times of India for the
West/North. Readers liked this and other changes I introduced. I got
compliments from wellknown professional like V. M. Kulkarni and others.
After 18 months – infact two years because of
back log) I insisted that I should be relieved of Editor. SWF Handed over
systematically – with proper records – financial/accounts subscribers etc.
There was no debt and there was a small balance handed over. When I was Editor
– B. S. Kumedan made a suggestion – we send SWF as a professional Journal in
exchange for other foreign Journals – from UK ,
USA ,
thus get these Journals to the DSSW Library without paying huge subscription,
in foreign exchange.
This worked well for some years – ended when
SWF, after me once again became irregular and journal not reaching foreign
Journals who had agreed for the exchange. I consider this phase of my
professional career – an important achievement and a contribution to the
profession.
Post – Script
Slice of Life – was a continuation of this
writing. Excerpts from that - computer – printed – (Courtesy Malati) draft copy
was sent to a few academies and DSSW Alumni. Rest was destroyed! Glimpses of My Life –
but not autobiography.